International Implications for School Leaders on the English-Only Default in Bilingual Education
Keywords:
School leadership, Bilingual Education, English Learners, Dual Language Program, International Comparison, teacher capacityAbstract
This integrative review examines peer-reviewed research on bilingual education outcomes across five national and regional contexts (Canada, Australia, the United Kingdom, the European Union, and the United States) and analyses the implications of this evidence base for school leadership practice. Despite decades of research demonstrating the academic and linguistic benefits of bilingual instructional approaches for students learning English as an additional language, English-only instruction remains the default programming model in most English majority nations. This review synthesises findings from longitudinal studies, national assessments, and comparative analyses to identify a recurring pattern across many studies. Bilingual and dual language programs are associated with equal or greater academic outcomes compared to English only models, particularly in the early years of schooling and over sustained periods of implementation. Drawing on the Leadership for Learning (LfL) framework, the review argues that school leaders play a pivotal but underexamined role in perpetuating or disrupting the English only default through their programming decisions. The review identifies three shared barriers to evidence-informed language programming across national context insufficient leadership preparation in language education, teacher workforce limitations and policy-practice gaps), and proposes a set of principles for language-informed school leadership. Implications for leadership preparation programs, international collaboration, and future research are discussed.