Discussion of: Steven H. Hill and Patrick McLaren, 2001. A Comparison between Log-hyperbolic and Model-independent Grain Size Distributions in Sediment Trend Analysis (STA®). Journal of Coastal Research, 17(4), 931-935.

Authors

  • Daniel Hartmann
  • Burg Flemming

Abstract

In a recent paper, HILL and McLAREN (2001) have compared the performance of two sets of descriptive grain-size statistics in predicting sediment transport directions. The one set makes use of "model-independent" textural parameters (mean, sorting and skewness) generated directly from the raw grain-size data, the other uses the same statistical parameters but in this case derived from "log-hyperbolic" estimated curves fitted to the same raw grain-size data. Both sets of statistics correctly predicted the direction of transport with essentially the same statistical significance. HILL and McLAREN (2001) conclude that the use of the log-hyperbolic distribution provides no advantage to the application of their STA® procedure. We are writing the present discussion (a) to elucidate the term "descriptive statistics" in relation to the log-hyperbolic Probability Density Function (PDF) and the so-called moment statistics and (b) to express our opinion on Sediment Trend Analysis (STA) and how it should be used in sediment transport studies.

Downloads

Published

2002-07-04

Issue

Vol. 18 No. 3 (2002): Journal of Coastal Research

Section

Discussion and Reply

License

Authorization for personal use is granted by the Coastal Education and Research Foundation [CERF]. By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for their article is transferred to the publisher if the article is accepted for publication. Assignment of copyright is not required, however, from authors who work for organizations which do not permit such assignment, The copyright covers the exclusive rights to reprduce and distribute the article, inclduing reprints, photographic reproductions, microform, or any other reproductions of a similar nature, and translations.